4 out of 5 stars.

It is not necessary to make separate icons for 256x256 and the 48x48 icons.

When you have the editor open, look at the left side. In the "Images" box you will see a small blue plus sign. Click it and it will allow you to add another image in another size. The two icons for each size that you have uploaded actually already contain both sizes. To see what I mean, click on one of your icons here on the site to see their previews. You will see both sizes.

That is the way that icons work- they package multiple sizes of pictures into one file.

The design is rather interesting. I do like the simple look. Not every icon should be simple, eye candy is cool sometimes, but simple icons can be good as well. I like the variety of sea creatures, it would be cool if you continued to add more fish to the set as you can. I imagine it would be an appealing set for younger children. Nice work, and I look forward to more submissions from you.

3 out of 5 stars.

The design is cute! But keep practicing your drawing skills . Dont worry that was me like a year ago. We will be hoping to see some more icons and cursors from you soon!

4 out of 5 stars.

I must say that I was quite blunt in my last pm to you and regret not finding a nicer way to convey my message. I apologize for that and hope you understand why I sent the pm.

These are actually quite nice Dude!!

Very original and different from each other!
I even like the coloring!

Maybe the set is more of a sea creatures set if you add more than just the fish. I really like this set!.. esp the octopus!
I looked at the set and tried to decide which I like best but I like that one too, and I like that one, and that one.. ya know?!
You are definitely moving up and improving!
Nice work, keep up the good work!
If you add to this set let me know so I can re-evaluate the rating!
What software are you currently using?